Circular Saw Vs. Jigsaw Vs. Reciprocating Saw: Get The Right Tool For Your Job



Accounts

Free Trial

Projects

SSL

Storage

Li-Ion Circular Saw

51sCt463JnL. SL250 removebg preview

Brand - DEWALT

Blade Length - 6.5 Inches

Color - Yellow

Battery Powered

Easy to use

Reciprocating Saw

DeWalt DCS387B 20 Volt Max Compact Reciprocating Saw removebg preview

Brand - DEWALT

Battery Powered

Weight - 5.4 Pounds

Lightweight

Easy to Use

Jig Saw

41UqC7az0cS. SL250 removebg preview

BLACK+DECKER

Color - Black

Corded Electric

Easy to use

Weight - ‎4.6 pounds

Circular Saw

Invented in the late 18th century and used in sawmills in the US, a circular saw uses a toothed or abrasive disc or blade to rip various materials. With the aid of a rotary motion spinning around an arbor, it cuts wood and other materials. This power saw also called a “Skil Saw” can be fitted to a purpose machine or used as a handheld tool.

In woodworking terms, the handheld type, the table saw, and chop saw are common circular saws.

circular saw can cut wood, masonry, plastic even metal and can either be powered by electricity, a gasoline engine or hydraulic motor.

See Also:

Jigsaw

A Jigsaw refers to a type of power tool that comprises an electric motor and a reciprocating saw blade. In addition to normal vertical stroke, a jigsaw can cut angles up to 45 degrees especially the one with bevel feature. Some manufacturers refer to jigsaws as bayonet saws or sabre saws. A jigsaw utilizes an attached blade accessory to saw wood.

Reciprocating Saw

A reciprocating saw refers to a machine-powered saw which cuts by a push and pull (reciprocating) motion of the blade. A reciprocating saw also called a hognose, recip saw, or Sawzall has a large blade like a jigsaw’s. It has a handle which affords it the ability to be used comfortably on vertical surfaces. It comes with a foot at the base of the blade, and the user holds or rests this foot on the cutting surface. The foot keeps the saw steady when working and give the user control over the tool. [1]

Comparison: Circular Saw Vs. Jigsaw Vs. Reciprocating Saw

Here we did a comprehensive analysis of the three saws basing our judgment on specific properties and hereunder lies the report. After reading this report, you must be able to differentiate one from the other. These saws have their individual uses, merits, and demerits and anyone can deliver the job assigned. Do read on for more:

Circular Saw Jigsaw Reciprocating Saw
51sCt463JnL._SL250_ 41UqC7az0cS._SL250_ 31Z-At3F5RL._SL250_
Types of Cuts:
It makes crosscuts and cut patterns easily.
It can rip different materials, e.g., plywood, plastics, metal, etc.
Types of Cuts:
It makes straight and curved cuts
It cut angles from 90 degrees to 45 degrees.
Types of Cuts:
It cuts through different materials quickly
It does crosscuts and plunge cuts.
Pros:
It‘s lightweight and perfectly portable.
It comes in handy in ripping and necessary miter cuts.
It works perfectly in cutting solid wood.
It can cut different materials.
It can cut solid hardwood with ease.
It stands as the safest of the three.
It does flush cuts.
Pros:
It‘s handy and lightweight.
It can be cut refined and accurately on different materials.
It can make beautifully detailed work.
It can cut different materials.
It works perfectly for bevel and compound cuts.
It can cut plunge or middle cuts.
Pros:
It‘s very powerful in handling heavy-duty jobs.
It can cut any material without limitation.
You can maneuver it easily.
Its open blade makes it easy to see the work area and line of cut.
It does a great job in demolition and renovation projects.
Cons:
It stands as the most dangerous of the three saws.
It produces rough and splintery edges.
It does not do justice to curve cuts.
Cons:
It requires care to handle.
It cannot do heavy-duty work.
If used with force the unit can be damaged.
Cons:
It creates rough cuts
It does not cut with precision.
It can cause health issues due to prolonged use.
Performance:
It works well in splitting long straight board or hardwood and other materials.
Performance:
It works best in detailed precision works.
Performance:
It works best in renovation and demolition projects.

Top 2 Best Circular Saws On The Market

DeWalt DCS391B 20-Volt MAX Li-Ion Circular Saw

The DeWalt DCS381B Circular saw features a powerful 460 MWO, 5250 RPM motor. The motor delivers power and speed for the most demanding cuts with ease. The DCS391B, for job site durability, comes with high strength and lightweight magnesium shoe. The magnesium shoe also makes for long-term cut accuracy.

To make the DCS391B easy to control, it comes with an optimized rubber over molded comfort grip. However, the DCS391B sold separately, the battery not included.

Specifications:

  • Power Source: 1 Lithium-ion Battery
  • Voltage: 20 V
  • Arbor Size: 5/8 inch
  • Blade Type: Carbide Tipped Blade
  • Bevel Angle Capacity: 0 degrees to 50 degrees
  • Cut Depth at 45 degrees: 1-5/8 inches
  • Cut Depth at 90 degrees: 2-1/4 inches
  • Blade Diameter: 6-1/2 inches
  • No Load Speed: 5,250 rpm
  • Weight: 7.1 lbs

Unique Features:

  • The DCS391B has 0 to 50 degrees bevel capacity which makes for aggressive bevel cuts for several types of applications.
  • The blade of the circular saw can cut two times material at angles of 90 and 45 and more cuts per charge.
  • The power motor delivers at the most demanding cuts without stress.
  • It has high strength and lightweight magnesium shoes for durability and long-term accuracy of cut.
  • It has balance and control thanks to the optimized rubber over-molded comfort grip.
  • It comes with a 3-year limited warranty.

51sCt463JnL._SL250_

   Buy On Amazon

DeWalt DWE575SB 7-1/4 Inch Lightweight Circular Saw with Electric Brake

The DeWalt DWE575SB Circular saw, comes with an electric brake that stops the spinning blade after releasing the trigger. The power tool was made to be one of the lightest, and most well-balanced saws in its class weight just 8.8 pounds. It has a ball bearing lower guard that makes for durability. The lower guard also provides smooth retraction against dust contamination.

It has advanced lower guard geometry for bevel cuts with an integrated dust blower. The dust blower help clear the work line while the user works. The DWE575SB might be small but has incredible power. It will serve framers, concrete formers, general contractors, and re-modelers best.

Specifications

  • Power Source: Electricity (corded)
  • Amp: 15 A
  • Power Out: 1,950 watts
  • Arbor Size: 5/8 inch
  • Blade Type: Carbide Tipped Blade
  • Bevel Angle Capacity: 0 degrees to 57 degrees
  • Cut Depth at 45 degrees: 1.9 inches
  • Cut Depth at 90 degrees: 2.55 inches
  • Blade Diameter: 7-1/4 inches
  • No Load Speed: 5,100 rpm
  • Weight: 8.8 lbs

Unique Features:

  • The DWE575SB comes with various features to aid its durability, e.g., the ToughCord system provides three times more resistance to cord pull-outs when compared to others.
  • It features ergonomic handles and triggers for comfort and balance.
  • The safety system of the DWE575SB includes the electric brakes that stop the blade after two or three seconds after the release of the trigger.
  • With the electric brake, you can start repetitive cuts faster.
  • It performs some of the most demanding projects with its powerful motor.
  • The tool can deliver high-quality performance and smooth cutting because of its high-quality gears.
  • It has an onboard blade wrench storage which makes for easy storage and convenience for blade changes.
  • It comes with a handy and portable carrying case for moving the tool, thus making it easy to transport.
  • The DWE575SB as earlier mentioned can come compact and lightweight.
  • It comes with a 3-year limited warranty.

Order yours now on Amazon:

DeWalt DWE575SB 7-1-4 Inch Lightweight Circular Saw with Electric Brake

   Buy On Amazon

Top 2 Best Jig Saws On The Market

Black + Decker BDEJS600C Smart Select Jig Saw, 5.0-Amp

Black & Decker’s BDEJS600C comes loaded with features among which include Curve Control technology. The Curve Control technology allows the user to adjust the saw’s orbit in 1 of 4 customized settings for specific projects. The tool comes with a 5-Amp variable-speed motor that creates up to 3,000 SPM of cutting power.

Specifications:

  • Power Source: Electricity (corded)
  • Amp: 5 A
  • Voltage: 120V
  • Cutting Power: 3,000 SPM
  • Bevel Angle Capacity: 45 degrees
  • Weight: 5.2 lbs

Unique Features:

  • Curve Control Technology: Gives the BDEJS600C an adjustable orbit in 1 of 4 customized settings to foster ease of completion of specific projects.
  • Great Cutting Power: with the cutting power of up to 3,000 SPM, the BDEJS600C can deliver on specific jobs.
  • Variable Speed Motor: Equipped with a 5-amp variable-speed motor for versatility.
  • It comes with an adjustable shoe which makes for a stable cutting platform.
  • Wire Guard features help in precision cuts
  • It comes with a 2-year limited warranty

Order yours here on Amazon:

41UqC7az0cS._SL250_

   Buy On Amazon

DeWalt DCS331B 20-Volt Max Li-Ion Jig Saw

The DeWalt DCS331B comes loaded with features to give you the best of cuts. It comes with a keyless blade for quick blade change. For speed, it comes with 4-position orbital action. When you purchase this DeWalt jigsaw, you can rest assured that you made a significant investment in power tools.

Specifications

  • Power Source: Battery-powered
  • Amp: 5 A
  • Voltage: 20V
  • Bevel Angle Capacity: 0 degrees, 15 degrees, 30 degrees, and 45 degrees
  • Weight: 5.7 lbs

Unique Features:

  • It comes with an excellent anti-slip comfort grip for the much-needed comfort and control
  • The DCS331B can accept T-shank jig saw blades for excellent holding power and professional results.
  • It comes with a keyless blade for quick blade change
  • It comes with a keyless shoe bevel with detents at 0 degrees, 15 degrees, 30 degrees, and 45 degrees making for versatility and easy bevel cutting
  • It comes with a 3-year limited warranty

Order yours here on Amazon:

DeWalt DCS331B 20-Volt Max Li-Ion Jig Saw

   Buy On Amazon

Top 2 Best Reciprocating Saws On The Market

Black + Decker BDCR20B 20V Max Lithium Bare Reciprocating Saw

The BDCR20B comes with a tool-free blade change feature. It comes with a powerful 3,000 SPM motor that has a variable speed trigger. For control, the electric brake gives you all you that. The BDCR20B has a lightweight and versatile feature for ease of use.

Specifications

  • Power Source: Battery-powered
  • Amp: 5 A
  • Max Voltage: 20V
  • Nominal Voltage: 18V
  • Strokes Per Minute: 0-3,000 strokes/minute
  • Stroke Length: 7/8 inches
  • Tool Weight: 4.6 lbs

Unique Features:

  • It comes with a tool-free blade change feature for quick blade change
  • It has electric brakes and a variable speed trigger for better tool control
  • It has an adjustable pivot shoe to enhance easy usage.
  • It comes with a 2-year limited warranty.

Get your own here on Amazon:

31Z-At3F5RL._SL250_

   Buy On Amazon

DeWalt DCS387B 20-Volt Max Compact Reciprocating Saw (Tool Only)

The DeWalt DCS387B comes to your rescue for all your renovation and demolition projects. It comes with a compact and lightweight design that makes it easy to use even in tight spaces. It comes with an easy blade change feature, and a clear bright LED light to help light-up dark areas. The DCS387B combines power and advanced technology.

Specifications

  • Power Source: Battery-powered
  • Wattage: 20 watt
  • Max Voltage: 20V
  • Nominal Voltage: 18V
  • Strokes Per Minute: 0-2,900 strokes/minute
  • Stroke Length: 1-1/8 inches
  • Tool Weight: 5.4 lbs

Unique Features:

  • It comes with a keyless lever-action which makes for fast and easy blade change.
  • It comes with a 4-position blade clamp usable for different application
  • It comes with a variable speed trigger which provides blade control needed for precision cuts.
  • It comes with pivoting shoes for cutting versatility
  • It’s compact and lightweight. The design makes it easy to use the unit in tight spaces.
  • It comes with a 3-year limited manufacturer’s warranty.

Why not order yours here on Amazon:

DeWalt DCS387B 20-Volt Max Compact Reciprocating Saw

   Buy On Amazon

How Do You Tighten A Circular Saw Blade?

A loose saw blade can fly out of the power tool during operation and cause severe harm or injury. We, therefore, recommend periodic checking of your circular saw blade. If the saw blade seems not well-fitting to the arbor, tightening it should be your next duty. However, if you just bought your circular saw and you want to assemble it, then tightening the saw becomes necessary.

Check for the user’s manual for instructions on how to tighten the saw blade. If your circular saw came with a manual (which is always the case), then use the manual. On the other hand, follow our instructions if you bought a used circular saw without the user’s manual.

Here we put together a few simple DIY steps for tightening your circular saw blades:

1. Safety First:

Unplug the power saw and take it to a clean table in a lighted room.

2. Tool Check:

Check for the spanner or Allen key that came with your power saw or a socket wrench. You will use any of the available tools to tighten the arbor nut that holds down the blade.

3. Secure the Saw:

Check for the shaft lock on your saw and use it to lock the blade down to stop its spinning movement while you tighten the arbor nut. However, if your saw does not have a shaft lock, use a clamp or vise grips to secure it from spinning.

4. Confirm the blade’s direction of rotation:

Usually, the arbor nut tightens in the opposite direction of the blade’s rotation. The reason for such a rotational arrangement is that when the blade spins in one direction and the nut in another, the nut will remain secure.

However, if the blade rotates in the same direction as the nut, the rotation of the blade would unscrew the bolt, and it would fly out!

Therefore, right-handed circular saw blades turn anticlockwise so you should tighten the bolt clockwise. However, left-handed circular saw blades rotate clockwise, thus tightening the bolt anticlockwise.

5. Tighten the nut:

Hold the rim or outer flange of the nut with a wrench to stop it from spinning. Use your other hand to hold the spanner, Allen key, or socket wrench to tighten the nut in the opposite direction the blade rotates. After tightening the nut, confirm if the blade sits firmly on the arbor.

As earlier said, conduct a periodic check on your saw because a well-maintained power tool will serve you well without causing accidents.

Caution: If you have challenges tightening your saw blade yourself or cannot see yourself doing it, contact a repairer.

Jigsaw Tips and Essentials

Jigsaws delivers cleaner, smoother and accurate cuts if you use it appropriately. We put together a few tips and essentials that can help you make judicious use of the power tool. [2]

1. Protect The Work Surface

Hold down the saw firmly to keep the blade from chattering. It may vibrate a bit but control it. The downward force and vibration can damage the work surface. Please apply a layer or two of masking tape to the base of the saw to reduce marring; you can remove it after.

2. Cut Anything

Your jigsaw cuts not only wood but steel, copper, or any metal, plastics, ceramic tiles, fiber, cement siding, and so on. Note that to achieve the feat, choose the adequate blade for each material.

3. Square The Blade

To cut straight and perfect cuts, ensure your blade stands perpendicular to the base. The cut will come out square-edged if the blade isn’t bent.

4. Cut With The Good Side Down

The majority of jigsaws cuts on the upstroke, and when it does, chips and flakes show on the wood surface. If you own such a jigsaw, place the good side of wood down while cutting. Conversely, you can buy a reverse cut or down-cut blades that saw on the downstroke.

5. Make a Metal Sandwich

In cutting sheet metal, place the metal between two sheets of ¼-inch plywood. That arrangement will result in low rattling. With the plywood holding the metal down, you will have a seamless noise-free cut.

6. A Blade for Every Occasion

As earlier said, vary the blade with the material you cut. Please do note that the larger the teeth, the more aggressive and rougher the cut and vice versa.

7. Use a Fence for Perfectly Straight Cuts

Apart from curves, jigsaws can also cut straight lines, compound and beveled cuts. To make straight lines, hold the workpiece firmly and guide the saw against a saw fence. Use also rails to raise the workpiece to avoid driving the saw into the benchtop which can cause bending and breaking of the blade.

What Is A Reciprocating Saw Used For?

Whatever your project type – significant construction or home use, the reciprocating saw will do the magic. The reciprocating saw is a versatile power tool that can do so many things. It can cut wood, metal, plastic, etc. It can do quick jobs though without much precision. You can maneuver it freely with your hand without so much as a guiding system.

The underlined make up the uses of a reciprocating saw:

1. Drywall Replacement

Replacing a damaged area of drywall can be a delicate job, especially with the conduit wiring and piping system. If you do not take care, you might destroy an electric cable or pipe within the wall. Therefore, a reciprocating saw will ensure you get the job done clean and without error. Just fit drywall saw blade on the tool and you can cut through the areas you need without destroying the cables or pipes.

2. PVC or Metal Pipe Cutting

As a plumber, electrician or installer, the reciprocating saw should form part of your essential tools. With a reciprocating saw fitted with a double-faced blade, you can cut PVC pipes, metal pipes, etc. You can also make perfect access holes for electric and pipework.

3. Cutting Stubborn Nails and Pins

At times a piece of furniture or construction might require dismantling and removing the nails and pins. Such tasks can quickly be done using a reciprocating saw. The saw comes with thin blades that can fit into any cracks to cut the nails or pins through.

4. Pruning Trees and Brushes

You can use a reciprocating saw in gardening. Because you can maneuver it easily, then you can use it to groom trees and bushes.

5. Cutting Metal

You can employ the use of a reciprocating saw to cut nails, metal sheets, pipes, and other types of metals.

6. Demolition

During demolition work, a reciprocating saw remains your sure bet. When demolishing in tight spaces, the saw will deliver. It delivers fast and powerful cuts even in the tightest of spaces. No matter the material that makes up the demolition work, be it wood, metal, bricks, tiles, etc., the saw will rip them apart.

7. Renovation and Construction

A reciprocating saw can quickly get you through so many projects, from construction to renovation jobs, you need not worry. Fitting windows and doors, and removing floor or wall tiles and linoleum can be done easily by the push-and-pull motion of the saw.

FAQs:

We have highlighted above just a few of the many uses of the reciprocating saw. The reciprocating saw utilizes its push-and-pull motion to get jobs done. However, a series of accessories abound that can be attached to it – versatility. The accessories come with different functions, and when connected to the saw, their functions come to play.

Q: Left-handed and Right-Handed circular saw, what is the difference?

A: Some people confuse the two to mean the hand the user can use to operate the saw which is not true. A left-handed circular saw has its blade positioned on the left side of the handle while a right-handed circular saw has its blade positioned on the right side of the handle.

Q: Can wood cut circular saw blade cut metal?

A: Absolutely not. The arbor sizes of the two are different. Manufacturers purposely made it so, to ensure the correct blade usage always. Metal cutting blades are more expensive than wood cutting blades.

Q: Is there any recommended thickness for the jigsaw blades for cutting stainless steel?

A: No. The only recommendation will be general, i.e., for thick materials like stainless steel get blades with fewer teeth per inch (TPI). E.g., for 24-gauge material use an 18-24 TPI blade.

Q:  Why the orbital setting on a jigsaw?

A: A jigsaw with an orbital setting can follow a circular movement that affords you the ability to cut faster in a straight line. The more the orbital action, the faster the saw and vice versa.

Q: Can I use just about any saw blade with my reciprocating saw?

A: Certainly yes. Your reciprocating saw blades can fit all reciprocating saws. It has a universal shank made to work with any reciprocating saw.

Q: Which of the reciprocating saw blades cut wood best?

A: The more aggressive tooth pitch of 6-10 TPI can cut nail embedded wood. It can also cut 6 x 6 inches posts and small tree limbs. A 5/8 TPI or 10/14 TPI combination blade can also rip wood. The blade can measure from 6 to 12 inches in length. However, to prevent the chances of bending the blade, as the length of the blade increase, the thickness should also increase.

Conclusion

After such a rich post, you should be feeling like a professional saw expert now. You can now differentiate one blade from the other. Now you can either buy a circular saw, a jigsaw, or a reciprocating saw for your work need. The project at hand should be your guide as you hit the mouse to make your purchase now.

Recall when you need precision work, then marry the jigsaw, but when heavy-duty demolition or renovation work beckons, your companion should be a reciprocating saw. The circular saw too has its impressive functions for your other projects. Why wait, click the mouse now and start sawing away!

Why Choose us?

We at MorningHomestead have vowed to give your quality with compromise as it relates to homesteading topics and valuable product reviews. Recall that we always deliver beyond your expectation and that we shall continue to do.

We enjoy love hearing from you lovely readers, thus leave your message and do not forget to share this post. Finally, we appreciate you for investing your time to read this post. Cheers!

Leave a Comment